New York's emptiest apartments are about to start paying rent.

A state appeals court on Wednesday cleared the way for Mayor Zohran Mamdani's pied-à-terre tax, reversing a lower-court ruling that had paused the rollout of the surcharge on luxury second homes. The tax, first proposed by Mamdani and signed into law by Governor Kathy Hochul in May, applies to single-family homes worth $5 million or more and co-ops and condos worth at least $1 million. It is projected to raise about $500 million a year for city services.

The homeowners who sued were not, strictly speaking, objecting to the tax. They were objecting to the list. A Staten Island judge had ruled in September that the rollout unlawfully burdened owners with proving their residency status and targeted some 900,000 residential properties through a public supplemental roll that included owners' personal details. The appeals panel disagreed: appearing on a publicly available property roll, the judges wrote, is not a concrete injury, since tax assessors publish much of the same information already.

Mamdani celebrated the ruling in a statement, saying the court had "rejected an attempt by the ultra-wealthy to avoid paying their fair share." The homeowners' lawyer, Randy Mastro, said the court had avoided addressing the merits and vowed to keep fighting on his clients' behalf. The merits, it turns out, are a separate appointment.

Like your satire sourced?

Get the Dispatch — the week's sharpest offenses, with receipts attached.

Two other lawsuits arguing the tax itself is unconstitutional — because it discriminates against non-residents of New York City — are still pending, with arguments due in December. For now, the rollout goes ahead, and owners should expect bills in the next couple of weeks. The penthouses, famously, will not be home to receive them.

The underlying reporting is filed in the Evidence Locker: Commercial Observer (Nov. 4, 2026); Homes.com (Nov. 5, 2026).